Once upon a time I used to make these peanut butter cookies. And they were pretty good and everyone liked them. And I made them loads but the more I made them the more I began to feel that they just weren’t that good after all, some was missing. Something just wasn’t quite right. They weren’t peanut buttery enough. They weren’t quite chewy enough, but they weren’t exactly crispy either. Small chocolate chips melted into them too much but chocolate chunks stopped them spreading on the tray. Eventually I stopped making them.
Time went on though and I started to miss peanut butter cookies, but I couldn’t go back to that stupid old rubbish recipe that I used to make. Bleugh. Those cookies were disgusting. Luckily this time I knew exactly where to go for a truly satisfying cookie recipe, the same place I found my beloved raspberry buttermilk cake, smitten kitchen.
So there you have it, perfect nutty flavour, chewy texture and lovely squishy dark chocolate chips (the recipe calls for peanut butter chips, but I just used all chocolate since we don’t get peanut butter chips here. I’m not even really sure what they are – just solid bits of peanut butter?). The recipe yields loads, I think I made about 25 and still had about a quarter of the dough to freeze for a cookie emergency.
I’m desperate to make them again, but there are so many amazing looking cookie recipes on Smitten Kitchen that I feel like it would be a waste to to not try something else, so I might be making two different types of cookie this weekend.







